Dude Weather Subscribe to Secrets Minneapolis / St. Paul

MNSpeak: Talk

160,106,737 Bottles of Grain Belt

From the Minneapolis/St. Paul
Business Journal
: A new report
from Minnesota's legislative auditor
shows that the state's restrictive liquor laws cost consumers $100 million a
year (or 160,106,737 bottles of Grain Belt, or 104,393,214 bottles of Summit). Minnesota grocers
hate the law, but the
Licensed Beverage Association says changing it will hurt small businesses.

29 Reader Comments

alexis02:09am
Mar 9

Good post, Matt.

Man, F the MLBA.

matt  url02:11am
Mar 9

Thanks. It's funny how you always seem to be around when I'm posting at 1 or 2 in the morning...

hipmn02:28am
Mar 9

Hey, you two, you're not alone in here, so behave.

In other news, I want to buy my liquor at the Somali grocery across the street from me.

matt  url02:30am
Mar 9

I could go for a Grain Belt and some Somali food right about now. Or any beer and food for that matter.

alexis02:44am
Mar 9

I'm usually up until 2 or 3. Self-employment RULEZ.

Comments sponsored by
matt  url02:48am
Mar 9

Agreed.

hipmn03:53am
Mar 9

Well, unemployment sucks. Beer would make it better.

CFKC (not verified)08:02am
Mar 9

Well, I do have a job which I'm about to go to, but I would like to talk about beer later...say around 5:30 or so this afternoon.

More to the point, can somebody please explain why we can't buy beer in grocery stores or cars on Sundays? Two dirty words in my opinion: lobbies and churches.

jderusha08:58am
Mar 9

It seems to backward: no booze on Sunday? I do some of my best drinking on Sunday. I used to live in Milwaukee... where they'll sell you beer at day care centers. Heck, the Catholic Churches would sell you liquor on Sunday if they could couple it with a polka festival.

And what's the deal with car dealers being closed too? I'm sure they like having the day off... and I like being able to look around without salesmen... but it seems very outdated.

champs09:01am
Mar 9

Allegedly, business wants to operate without regulatory encumbrances, but as far as I know, the MLBA *likes* the fact that they have restrictive operating hours enshrined by law. I think the Minnesota Auto Dealers Association likes their blue laws, too.

The feeling is that later hours and a seven day schedule would eat away at their net profit, because they'd simply run longer to make the same amount of money... that might work for cars, but I'm sure I'm not the only one who's cursed the fact that it's after 8 or 10PM (depending on the night) more than once.

Slim (not verified)09:38am
Mar 9

Anyone ever looked into the constitutionality of business regulation that has no other purpose than to limit competition? e.g. the Sunday auto dealership closing. I see they are sure having the auto show open Sunday.

Mpls Simpletonq (not verified)09:40am
Mar 9

The big problem with this being passed is the amount of cities in Minnesota with Municipal Liquor stores. I'm pretty sure Anoka, Columbia Heights, Morris, St. Anthony Village, etc are not going to give up the cash cow of public funding that is liquor sales.

Even if they pass a state law it is still up to city governments to set their own liquor laws that can be more restrictive than state laws. So if you live or shop in those cities you will be out of luck.

ohthehumanity (not verified)09:47am
Mar 9

Since when does a can of Grain Belt cost $360?

Andy (not verified)12:08pm
Mar 9

Wow, that's some fuzzy math.

If Grain Belts costs $11.99 for a 12 pack then that's: 11.99/12 = $0.99 a bottle. So

100,000,000/277,978 is $438.64 a bottle.

Is that what they're charging in Northfield these days?

matt  url12:21pm
Mar 9

Grain Belt costs 14.99 for a 24 BOTTLE pack. I took the price as $1 less than Simon Delivers sells it for. That's probably still a bit high. 100,000,000/14.99 = 6,671,114 - 24 packs. 6,671,114*24 = 160,106,737 bottles of Grain Belt.

Summit = 104,393,214 @ 22.99 for a 24 pack.

I divided instead of multiplied the last part. Sue me. But my mistake at 1:30 in the morning only underplayed how f-ing stupid this law is.

matt  url12:38pm
Mar 9

Post changed.

TBartel12:32pm
Mar 9

All I can say is that at 11.99 for a twelve pack of Grain Belt, it cost me about 3500 twelve packs for a year's tuition for this knucklehead.

Of course, the whole thing could be explained by the fact that he posted this around 1 a.m. And, what's a college student likely to be doing at 1 a.m. that might impair his math abilities?

matt  url12:46pm
Mar 9

Does it say in the report anywhere when the law was enacted in the first place?

Just plain Bob (not verified)01:07pm
Mar 9

I wouldn't believe anything the Minnesota Licensed Beverage Association, says anymore. They have been talking outta both sides of their mouths for some time now.

Update for Simpleton: The Columbia Heights muni store closed years ago.

Luke (not verified)01:08pm
Mar 9

Let the cities set their own liquor laws. Sensible cities like Minneapolis and St. Paul can benefit if the state law changes.

Mpls Simpleton (not verified)01:19pm
Mar 9

Hate to burst your Bubble Bob but the Top Value liquor stores in Columbia Heights are run by the city.

ryan (not verified)04:29pm
Mar 9

My hometown has a municipal liquor store. Yes, there's nothing like walking in and seeing a 6-pack of Summit priced at nearly $8.00!

From the sound of it, the liquor laws in Minnesota are a bit archaic... it sounds as if the guys from Surly Brewing had to jump through a multitude of hoops just to get up and running and they're aren't even bottling beer yet.

If you recall, it took what seems like ages for Minnesota to actually allow brewpubs to sell growlers. I still think it's silly that they need to conform to the liquor store hours... of course I think liquor store hours (and 3.2 beer in gas stations and grocery stores) are silly. Of course I was spoiled, I went to college for a year in a city that bordered Fargo, North Dakota and their liquor stores are seemingly always open.

notthatmatt (not verified)04:33pm
Mar 9

I just moved here from Philadelphia (a year and a half now!) and while I agree that the no beer on Sunday thing is stupid, and the no booze at Cub sucks, it could be a lot worse. In Philly I had to buy beer either from a distributor with weird hours in strange parts of town, or six packs from the bar or deli. If you want wine or liquor you have to go to a state run store. I even heard rumors of people getting arrested for transporting alcohol into the state from Jersey illeagally. The Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board is the largest purchaser of wine and spirits in the United States which means that the state is one of the most powerful movers in the alcohol business. If they decide to buy your microbrew you are set.

Anyway even they decided to sell on Sunday...

mark06:53pm
Mar 9

I agree on no Sunday sales, but isn't this also about letting grocery stores sell booze? That I don't think I'd like. Grocery stores are brand whores, and stock what the distributors pay them to stock, i.e. shit.

I like good beer and you don't get that unless you go to a place that also appreciates good beer. Generally speaking, that wouldn't include any grocery stores I've ever shopped in.

alamn07:18pm
Mar 9

Don't you just hate it when a Mpls Simpleton bursts your bubble?

I stand corrected.

jmullan08:19pm
Mar 9

"We don't want liquor stores to be able to sell food because then people will stop going to grocery stores."
"Do you realise that in a few years you will be prevented from selling booze in your grocery store?"
"When would we ever want that?"

ryan (not verified)01:00pm
Mar 10

Hey Mark, I agree with you on grocery stores being brand whores, BUT some of them must carry the good stuff, even if it's not sitting on an endcap... my little sister returned from Arizona the other day and brought me a bottle of Stone Brewing's Arrogant Bastard that she'd purchased off a grocery store shelf. Great beer. I only wish I had more.

karl (not verified)03:16pm
Mar 10

The Mob has nothing on the beer distribution system in Minnesota, and in fact, it is a system that has its roots in the mob's prohibition liquor business. When prohibition ended, the distribution system remained intact. It's the most corrupt, bribery-ridden system imaginable. And they keep it that way by greasing the legislature well. Before John Marty cleaned up the system at the capitol, it was even worse. Legislators' refrigerators were magically filled every night by the "beer fairies." The whole three-tiered system that guarantees obscene profits to everyone but the beermakers should be deismantled.

mike m (not verified)03:50pm
Mar 14

With all the multi-culturism happening here, it seems that the christian sunday blue law thing should be obsolete, muslims worship on friday, jews on saturday, most don`t go to church at all.

Why are barbershops & chinese restaurants closed on mondays?

Try to call the MN Dept of Revenue on friday - closed, whats up with that?

Free market economy my ass!

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <i> <b> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <br> <p>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
By entering in the words in the captcha image, you help us prevent automated spam submissions and keep the site tidy.

Today's Talk

Seeking TC Blogs

All right, it is time to expand my RSS Reader again with local blogs I haven't read before. If you kow of or have a local blog that produces local content (and it doesn't need to all be local content; just occasional), go ahead and pimp it here.…

Max Sparber
20 comments »

July 4 Open Thread

WCCO has a list of where to see Independence Day fireworks; what are your July 4 plans?…

Max Sparber
33 comments »

Voting With Your Dollar

An interesting discussion broke on on Twitter today when it came out that Baja Sol's CEO is also the chair of the Republican Party in Minneapolis, prompting some to decide not to eat there (summary and links to the conversation courtesy of Heavy Tabl…

Max Sparber
51 comments »

Kline: Public Health Care 'Too Good'

From the Health Insurance Resouce Center: Interviewed on Minnesota Public Radio, Kline says as far as he's concerned, a health reform bill with a public option is a no-go. His reasoning is that it would be ... too successful. (Via)…

Max Sparber
8 comments »

Next MnRead... The What/When/Where

At 8:30 AM on a Thursday in early July, I am unable to think of what books were recommended at the last MnRead meeting and in the last MnRead post for future MnRead discussion. So make your recommendations here. Books with local angles (Fitzgerald co…

kurtis
4 comments »

More Burger Joints!

The PiPress reports: At least, there's one good thing about a bad economy: Burgers are hot right now. Especially the cheap ones. In the past year in the Twin Cities, a mini burger boom has been under way. What new burger joints have you enjoyed? Wha…

Max Sparber
43 comments »

Read more of today's talk…