Dude Weather Subscribe to Secrets Minneapolis / St. Paul

MNSpeak: Talk

The Rake Suspends Print Publication

The Rake announced today that it will cease print publication. The March 2008 issue, which hit newsstands today, will be the last. Rakemag.com will continue to operate. Read Brad Zellar's eulogy.

82 Reader Comments

Zosia (not verified)11:14am
Feb 25

Man, this is so disappointing. The Rake was really the local print publication I liked.

Zosia (not verified)11:15am
Feb 25

I mean, I know it'll be online - but still.

PRINT IS DEAD (not verified)11:28am
Feb 25

PRINT IS DEAD

JACC11:29am
Feb 25

I think it's incorrect to Call Brad Zellar's piece a "Eulogy".

Taking umbrage is not the same as paying tribute.

It's sad to see the Rake print copy go.

ericam  url11:31am
Feb 25

I hope it doesn't pull a TC Pulse and pull the plug on the website in a week.

Now I'm definitely interested in seeing if they do anything differently with the website. I suppose they can sell off that $220,000 worth of equipment.

Comments sponsored by
ericam  url11:38am
Feb 25

The lovefest in the comments on Zellar's bit is touching.

ryanol (not verified)11:43am
Feb 25

something tells me a healthy portion of that 220K is in racks that aren't worth the time or shipping cost to sell them.

I wonder how if vita.mn is next?

JACC11:44am
Feb 25

@ericam - Thanks, I missed the comments.

bud jr (not verified)11:47am
Feb 25

CP should run it as a quarterly insert.

ericam  url11:52am
Feb 25

Why do you wonder about vita.mn?

foof (not verified)11:52am
Feb 25

Holy shit, that's crazy. They'd slid a little in quality in the past few years, but still, it's depressing to see a stinkball like METRO stay in print while the Rake gives it up.

justpbob  url11:52am
Feb 25

(wipes tear)

Thanks for a free print mag that was worth reading, Tom.

matt  url11:54am
Feb 25

"Taking umbrage is not the same as paying tribute. "

At the Rake it is.

acalhoun11:54am
Feb 25

Thanks for another good rag, T-Bar. It will be missed.

JACC11:56am
Feb 25

Bravo!

Matt, please refrain from making me burst out laughing at work. They already think I'm strange enough.

jderusha11:57am
Feb 25

That is funny, Matt. I'm sorry if my comments about slutty dresses sunk The Rake for good.

justpbob  url12:01pm
Feb 25

I hear you, Jason. The Pulse of the TC folded soon after it published my piece on biodiesel.

JACC12:02pm
Feb 25

. . . and now the two of you have commented side-by-side on Mnspeak.

Max Sparber  url12:03pm
Feb 25

Let me get my resume prepared. Thanks, Bob and Jason.

chuckt12:15pm
Feb 25

From the release:

The Rake will continue to publish online at www.rakemag.com, with its Secrets of the Day emails, event calendar, searchable restaurant database, and select blogs.

Does that mean the features and Rakish Angle are dead?

ryanol (not verified)12:42pm
Feb 25

sorry erica @ I meant I wonder how long vita.mn the rag will exist.

I just am not sure about display advertising to hipsters (18-35 urban youth) as a print media business model.

does vita.mn employ reps that are independent or are they regular strib ad reps simply selling another sku?

yoder  url12:44pm
Feb 25

This sucks. Even though I read the online more often than the print it still sucks.

vlado412:44pm
Feb 25

With the cost savings the internet provides, is running PRINT media really worthwhile?

I read online stuff way more than paper.

I welcome the Rake embracing technology and abandoning an expensive, outdated, and environmentally unfriendly distribution method.

Print to Internet I would like to see next: MnDaily, Citypages, vita.mn,

kwatt12:46pm
Feb 25

This sucks. THe Rake was always something I could count on to pick up at virtually every Minneapolis restaurant when I'm dining alone.

tinnie (not verified)12:51pm
Feb 25

Good grief! Whose going to reject my short stories now???

acalhoun12:54pm
Feb 25

when I'm dining alone

No comment. Help override the transpo veto, and you'll have your share of dinner mates, Kevin.

s4xton  url01:00pm
Feb 25

A few more details from David Brauer, including how "Bartel said 15 of the company's 16 employees will be laid off..."

ericam  url01:08pm
Feb 25

sorry erica @ I meant I wonder how long vita.mn the rag will exist.

That's what I thought you meant, but I thought I'd ask.

does vita.mn employ reps that are independent or are they regular strib ad reps simply selling another sku?

That I don't know for sure, but I suspect it's the latter.

matt  url01:23pm
Feb 25

ChuckT - "Does that mean the features and Rakish Angle are dead?"

Yep.

cristina01:25pm
Feb 25

Thanks, for the kind word, folks. (It's a welcome change from the overwhelming negativity.)

And I assure you, we will continue online as long as you keep reading.

justpbob  url01:29pm
Feb 25

Count me in.

justpbob  url01:33pm
Feb 25

The final issue cover story is "Stop the Presses?"

Ouch.

bud jr (not verified)01:36pm
Feb 25

This market has the same print vehicles / population ratio as it has pro sports teams / population ratio.

Inverse to assured profitability.

Both the Rake and, currently, the Twolves paid the price.

just sayin' (not verified)01:39pm
Feb 25

With the cost savings the internet provides, is running PRINT media really worthwhile?

When the print edition was publishing = 16 employees.

No more print edition = 1 employee.

cristina01:46pm
Feb 25

Please don't discount our bloggers: That's at least an additional 7 (somewhere thereabout) valuable people.

cristina01:49pm
Feb 25

And MNSpeaker Rich Goldsmith will begin blogging for The Rake this week. Look for him here.

Tom B. (not verified)01:52pm
Feb 25

Just promise me Motley Kruse will be available online. I'd hate to go into moxie withdrawal.

ericam  url01:54pm
Feb 25

Sweet! I was enjoying Rich at Just Passing Through.

I enjoy the concept of Just Passing Through immensely, even if I don't always love the blogger du jour.

fkaJames01:59pm
Feb 25

Cristina: Who are the 7 bloggers? There are at least 11 active blogs with regular writers at rakemag.com, in addition to the "revolving cast of contributors" blogs like Outrage and Just Passing Through. Who's staying on board at this point? Iggers, Bauer, Robson, Zellar, god forbid Melinda Jacobs?

foof (not verified)02:27pm
Feb 25

And what the hell ever happened to Lambert, anyway? The updates just stopped cold.

miller02:34pm
Feb 25

I guess you didn't get the memo.

Tom B. (not verified)02:39pm
Feb 25

Am I completely out of touch with what Minnesotans want? Why is Brian Lambert incessantly provided high-profile venues in which to provide his "insight"? Who decreed him the official finger-on-the-pulse guy for local media? Seems to me he fails at everything he tries, but always lands on his feet.

vlado402:40pm
Feb 25


With the cost savings the internet provides, is running PRINT media really worthwhile?

When the print edition was publishing = 16 employees.

No more print edition = 1 employee.

Umm so were 15 people directly involved with printing and distributing the paper version?

If not, they must've scaled down their operation and gotten rid of writers. That doesn't have much to do with paper vs. electronic. People can still write stuff online and have a wide audience.

I will admit, I am kinda sad about this. Rake was a cool mag. Made me feel like Minneapolis was a hip awesome city.

cristina02:43pm
Feb 25

We're still sorting out the details, so I don't want to make any promises, but we hope to keep the majority of our bloggers, and even add a few blogs to our list.

just sayin' (not verified)02:49pm
Feb 25

Umm so were 15 people directly involved with printing and distributing the paper version?

If not, they must've scaled down their operation and gotten rid of writers. That doesn't have much to do with paper vs. electronic. People can still write stuff online and have a wide audience.

I will admit, I am kinda sad about this. Rake was a cool mag. Made me feel like Minneapolis was a hip awesome city.

Since the Rake was free, advertising (I would assume mostly in the print edition) paid the salaries of those 15 employees who no longer have jobs.

I'm sure those bloggers are getting paid something, but I doubt it's anything close to a full salary.

v (not verified)02:49pm
Feb 25

Can it be a eulogy it it's written and posted before the news of the demise? Seems to be it's more a response to news the mag is up for sale. At least before the comments.

foof (not verified)02:52pm
Feb 25

I guess you didn't get the memo.

Whoa, guess not. Thanks.

ryanol (not verified)03:04pm
Feb 25

so how long till the rake goes UGC just like this heeyah site?

champs03:47pm
Feb 25

Rex was better when The Rake was here.

matt  url03:50pm
Feb 25

Thanks for that, Champs.

matt  url03:52pm
Feb 25

Sorry, just realized that could have been read as sarcastic. Wasn't.

kwatt04:05pm
Feb 25

when I'm dining alone

No comment. Help override the transpo veto, and you'll have your share of dinner mates, Kevin.

So are you going to line these up for me, or how's this gonna work? I like beef, chicken, breakfast foods, pastas, tacos and things with cheese. No Asian sh*t. Blech.

esquared (not verified)06:45pm
Feb 25

It's hard for me to come to grips with the print/online divide. I almost always prefer print, and only get annoyed when I'm recycling huge piles of newspapers. But I very rarely read the Rake online (I sometimes use their restaurant finder), and I doubt I'm going to start now. There's something about thumbing through a magazine (or newspaper) and seeing all of the content there, without any of it being hidden away because it's not the most read or most emailed. I still make a choice about what to read and what to skip, but with any online source, I tend to miss out on a lot because I'm too lazy to dig.

vita.mn, though...that works much better online. I don't know why they take crap from their website and print it in a newspaper.

cristina08:07pm
Feb 25

I was beginning to listen, until... vita.mn... whatever. If they're doing things right online, then I'm at a loss.

cristina08:30pm
Feb 25

Ok. I've had a couple of drinks now, and I probably shouldn't be posting, but ... I've never been good at keeping my mouth shut.

This whole 16-then and 1-now shit really has me bothered. It's not a one-man or one-woman show. Regardless of the unfortunate loss of print, there will still be more than 12 people regularly contributing to The Rake online (most of whom have been previous contributors)  hopefully more than that, once things settle down a bit.

While Bauer appears to be quoting T. Bartel in his MinnPostpiece  "Bartel said 15 of the company's 16 employees will be laid off"  this information is misleading and, in fact, quite destructive. Whether deliberate or not (and I honestly hope it's not), it's misleading information like this that augments the difficulties we (and all print-to-online publications) face today.

The Rake in print was a beautiful beautiful thing. That's why I went to work there in the first place. My only hope  something I will put all of myself into  is to live up to that online. Please stick around. (And for those of you who claim never to read us online, I hope we change your mind.)

taulpaul08:42pm
Feb 25

*Pours a facebook 40 ouncer gift in front of the Rake's website*

This if for my homies.

ummm... (not verified)08:44pm
Feb 25

It's hard to dispute that 15 people lost jobs and that there are 15 fewer media (ad and editorial) positions in the TC now. Sure -- lots of freelancers (making what per word or post?), but it doesn't change the effect on the job market.

Glad you're still around, Cristina, and that the Rake will be around in some form, but I don't think Brauer's analysis was meant to mislead or destroy anything.

TBartel10:54pm
Feb 25

My fault for the 15 of 16 information misunderstanding. That's what I told Brauer. I should have been more clear. The real fact is that several of the 15 will continue working for rakemag.com in some capacity, including contributing much of the same stuff they did before the closure of the print publication. Also, some bookkeeping, data entry and sales people will definitely continue to work on a contract basis. Most of our contributors, including Britt Robson, Brad Zellar, Ann Bauer, Jeremy Iggers and others will continue without interruption. I also plan to write more myself, which I'm sure will please my critics here on mnspeak.

While I'm here, I thought of correcting a lot of misinformation that cropped up on the "Rake for Sale" thread, but if I did, it would result in the longest comment in the history of mnspeak.

I'll just touch on one in particular. The figures quoted in the "listing" in the Brauer story were wildly inaccurate. Not Brauer's fault. The lister, in addition to violating his confidentiality agreement couldn't get the numbers right either.

My favorite comment though was from the person who suggested we try to sell ads. Gee I wish I'd thought of that sooner.

I also liked the one about printing not being expensive. That was a revelation, too.

Finally, I commend to you the piece Matt called the Rake's eulogy by Brad Zellar. Zellar is just one one phenomenal writers and thinkers who have graced the Rake's pages and website. Those of you who haven't admired Yo Ivanhoe or his features over the years have missed some amazing stuff. I esteem his friendship, and that of all the other people I've worked with at The Rake, far more than any profit we ever might have made in the future or all the treasure we have lost in the past six years.

taulpaul11:00pm
Feb 25

I gotta start asking the right questions when we talk Tom. Good Luck with the transition.

TBartel11:11pm
Feb 25

Oh, yeah. I forgot to mention, because it's so obvious to me, that Cristina, besides being a joy to work with, is an amazing talent as a creator of content and as an editor of other folks' work. That's a rare combination. It's hard for an outsider to see the amount of work she puts into our site every day. Believe me, it's a lot, and she's due all the credit for how good rakemag is.

OK, now I'm done.

grote (not verified)11:51pm
Feb 25

goddammit. I leave town for one day and this happens. what will I read on the toilet now?

Downtowner (not verified)01:33am
Feb 26

It's easy to recall Tom Bartel taking such great pleasure in publicly gloating whenever he'd sign up some next laid-off local journalist, as his latest addition at The Rake.

And now the Rake ceases print publication, and becomes a shoestring-budget competitor of what? MinnPost?

Rather than pile-on any more negativity here, I'll just stop at that.

Goose (not verified)01:57am
Feb 26

Great. More Bartel content. Is it me, or does the Rake decline parallel Bartel's decision to start writing that lead editorial? He'll never, ever learn, will he?

chuck04:05am
Feb 26

The Rake magazine was special. Thanks for all the words.

Cristina and the rakemag.com motley crew, I never left, so hello again. Hello.

David Brauer (not verified)07:40am
Feb 26

I just gotta say, I wish Tom had told me all this when I called about the listing last week. I'm really a reasonable guy, and I do call up everyone I write about.

I don't think, in the end, there's anything inaccurate about the 15-for-16 thing (and I appreciate Tom cleansing the record on my behalf). The simple fact is the Rake had 16 employees - and that's a powerful term for those of out here who buy our own health care and pay our own Social Security - and now they'll have 1.

It's ALSO true that some of those people will work for the Rake again, in what sounds like independent contracting roles if I read Tom right. But that's an additive bit of info that doesn't contradict the first. Exactly who sounds like it is way up in the air, so I don't blame anyone for not stressing it yesterday.

I realize I'm on some shit lists as a result of my reporting last week, but I am interested in knowing who Rake will carry forward when those decisions are made. And I'll happily write about it, because I think the blog mix is pretty good and I hope as much of it is preserved as possible.

cristina10:33am
Feb 26

Brauer, like I said, I accept the veracity of your initial statement, but to say that the source of our content is "an additive bit of info" is absolutely absurd when you're making it sound like a one-person show. And again, you're wrong about the bloggers being "way up in the air" as well. [Why do you insist on this bullshit, Brauer? I don't get it. It's this loaded attitude that gets you on those shit lists, not good journalism.] I simply thought it best to nail down all the details before shooting my mouth off. Our bloggers will include (but not necessarily be limited to) the following: Ann Bauer, Brad Zellar, Julie Caniglia, Britt Robson, Jeremy Iggers, Jimmy "Dutch" Gaines, Rich Goldsmith.

MollyP  url12:14pm
Feb 26

In David's defense, I would say that contract bloggers are different than full-time employees. David's point remains the same: There is no "business" of journalism anymore, and instead most writers are having to piece together a living instead of being able to rely on a consistent paycheck. What was once an outfit of 16 full-time employees is now reduced to one. That fact still remains.

taulpaul12:19pm
Feb 26

There is no "business" of anymore, and instead most are having to piece together a living instead of being able to rely on a consistent paycheck.

Is this a conversation about Unions, or are we gonna talk about developing a competitive landscape?

taulpaul12:21pm
Feb 26

The filter pulled out my brackets.

There is no "business" of "insert profession" anymore, and instead most "insert job title" are having to piece together a living instead of being able to rely on a consistent paycheck.

Crocodile Tears (not verified)01:00pm
Feb 26

Sorry to interrupt all Tom Bartel's weepy good feelings for all his great writers, but for a little reality you might want to check this trackback from Minneapolisyncrasy:

"And it's sad news for a friend of mine, a (now former) Rake employee who received a whopping four days of severance pay."

It's one thing to ladel on compliments on a website, quite another to reach into your pocket and help those great employees pay their rents and feed their families until they find another job ...

Anonymous (not verified)02:14pm
Feb 26

As one of the (now formers) there was no wheepy good vibe yesterday.

Max Sparber  url09:57am
Feb 27

To clarify, Tom B in this thread is the author of this blog.

2 wheels good (not verified)10:31am
Feb 27

As one of the (now formers) there was no wheepy good vibe yesterday.

"Have your shit out of the office by the end of the day" doesn't leave much time for fare-thee-wells, I'd suppose.

matt  url11:00am
Feb 27

Tom B, do you mind using your full name or a different pseudonym? Sorry to make you change, it's just causing a bit of confusion with Tom Bartel. Thanks.

And17 (not verified)12:23pm
Feb 27

No!
It's so sad. I'm really disappointed.

Anonymous (not verified)05:53pm
Feb 27

As another of the (now formers) I must have been in a different office. There was no good vibe but there was weepy shit from all sides. It wasn't easy day for anyone.

esquared (not verified)08:31pm
Feb 27

delayed reply to cristina: I don't really mean that vita.mn is this fabulous website - I rarely go there either. But when I do, I'm much more drawn to it because it feels like more of a social networking site instead of just news. Not that I'm a member, but it's an option. And since I think their overall content is pretty weak, I'd rather see it solely online and not in print. Waste of paper, in my opinion.

Anonymous (not verified)01:23pm
Feb 28

As another of the (now formers) I must have been in a different office. There was no good vibe but there was weepy shit from all sides. It wasn't easy day for anyone.

-For sure. But unemployment goes beyond not having an easy day.

domenic01:41pm
Feb 28

As another of the now formers - though former since June 07 - I'd like to point out that Brad Zellar never beat me in an office push up contest.

I'd also like to wish all my former colleagues the best.

David Brauer (not verified)09:55pm
Feb 28

Cristina - I gave Tom an opportunity to tell me all that. Although it's always fun to speculate on what's in others' heads, there was "no intent to make it sound like a one-man show" - in fact, the lead paragraph in my story noted the website would continue, with blogs.

My sense was that, a few hours into the print closing, no deals had been struck or re-ups cements - true at least in the case my friend Britt Robson, who is on your list and has since said he is remaining - and Tom was being careful about precipitating any agreements with his bloggers.

So I think you're reading something in there most objective readers didn't.

Stories are snapshots in time, and facts continue to emerge. That's why I keep asking questions, and why I'm interested in the answers. I'll make sure to call you up about the blogroll - should be an interesting conversation.

David Brauer (not verified)11:33pm
Feb 28

OK, a really bollixed-up graf, and I haven't even been drinking.

It was supposed to read thusly, with one addition:

My sense was that, a few hours into the print closing, no deals had been struck or re-ups cemented - true, at least, in the case of my friend Britt Robson (who is on your list and heard about the mag's closure from me. He has since said he is remaining, but wasn't sure of his status when we talked that day). I think Tom was being careful about precipitating any agreements with his bloggers, but that's just my guess.
Off to bed!

dman (not verified)09:17am
Apr 14

I'd like to see independent rags stay in business whether it's in print or online. I've been a dedicated fan of the Rake since 2003 and I think they have a great staff. I use their website a few times a month, but it would be nice to be able to pick up their paper and browse over it while having a cup of coffee. They could have saved some money on printing costs by reducing the size of their paper and going black and white on the cover. Maybe something more like the NorthEaster or North News.

If the Rake opts for more of a social networking website, which I think they were trying to do with their Rake Raters for restaurant reviews then they will have an unlimited source of writers.

However, I can't say the same for vita.mn. Sure they have a staff of writers and designers dedicated to their online website and repurposed for print, but they're just a mouthpiece for the Star Tribune corporation targeting 18-30 year olds. They're too yuppie and artificial. Can't wait to see vita.mn go out of business.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <i> <b> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <br> <p>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
By entering in the words in the captcha image, you help us prevent automated spam submissions and keep the site tidy.

Today's Talk

Seeking TC Blogs

All right, it is time to expand my RSS Reader again with local blogs I haven't read before. If you kow of or have a local blog that produces local content (and it doesn't need to all be local content; just occasional), go ahead and pimp it here.…

Max Sparber
20 comments »

July 4 Open Thread

WCCO has a list of where to see Independence Day fireworks; what are your July 4 plans?…

Max Sparber
33 comments »

Voting With Your Dollar

An interesting discussion broke on on Twitter today when it came out that Baja Sol's CEO is also the chair of the Republican Party in Minneapolis, prompting some to decide not to eat there (summary and links to the conversation courtesy of Heavy Tabl…

Max Sparber
51 comments »

Kline: Public Health Care 'Too Good'

From the Health Insurance Resouce Center: Interviewed on Minnesota Public Radio, Kline says as far as he's concerned, a health reform bill with a public option is a no-go. His reasoning is that it would be ... too successful. (Via)…

Max Sparber
8 comments »

Next MnRead... The What/When/Where

At 8:30 AM on a Thursday in early July, I am unable to think of what books were recommended at the last MnRead meeting and in the last MnRead post for future MnRead discussion. So make your recommendations here. Books with local angles (Fitzgerald co…

kurtis
4 comments »

More Burger Joints!

The PiPress reports: At least, there's one good thing about a bad economy: Burgers are hot right now. Especially the cheap ones. In the past year in the Twin Cities, a mini burger boom has been under way. What new burger joints have you enjoyed? Wha…

Max Sparber
43 comments »

Read more of today's talk…